Fire Island Beach House 25 Cayuga Walk 38 Room Hotel Ocean Bay Park, NY 11770 For Sale

Discover a rare chance to own a thriving beachside resort in the exclusive Ocean Bay Park community of Fire Island, New York. Just steps from both the Great South Bay and the Atlantic Ocean, The Fire Island Beach House offers a fully renovated, turnkey property with exceptional revenue potential.
This 38-room boutique resort comprises four multiunit buildings, two bungalows, and two private two-bedroom cottages with full kitchens—providing a diverse mix of accommodations designed to attract guests year after year. With value-add potential, the cottages and bungalows can be modernized for higher rates, further enhancing revenue streams. Originally built in the early 1900s for the Coast Guard, the property seamlessly blends historic charm with modern upgrades. Extensive renovations completed in 2020-2021 include all new bathrooms, ?re alarm system, siding, windows, and Timbertech decking, while a new pool liner and coping were installed in 2024.
The Fire Island Beach House delivers more than just exceptional accommodations—it offers an elevated beachside dining experience at Canes at the FIBH. Guests can enjoy their meals poolside, at the bar, high-top tables, or within the lounge area on the scenic back lawn. Professional management on food & beverage operations can further optimize catering and restaurant sales, creating an opportunity for higher profitability. Guests also enjoy poolside and lawn food & beverage service, a café kiosk, back lawn dining, quick snacks, tacos, and more!
While ownership does not currently allocate resources to securing weddings or retreats, special events remain an untapped opportunity for future growth.
Additionally, new membership offerings have drawn substantial interest, signaling strong demand and engagement from clientele.
A Proven Beachside Asset with Exceptional Revenue Potential!
Guests enjoy a private pool, vibrant bar & grill, and thoughtful amenities, including picnic tables, beach chairs, family-friendly games, and an ice machine—creating a truly memorable getaway for families, couples, and solo travelers alike.
With a strong ?nancial track record and well-established clientele, this turnkey hospitality asset is ready for a new owner to capitalize on its success. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a fully operational, income-generating beachside property in one of New York’s most sought-after destinations.
Contact Michael Murphy today to learn more and schedule a private tour.