Share This Listing

Message

963 characters remaining

Hmm, there seems to have been an error sending your message. Please try again.

Your email has been sent.

33 Jefferson St
Garden City, NY 11530
Specialty Property For Sale · 11,585 SF

Investment Highlights

  • Walk to Stewart Manor LIRR Station
  • Parking on Premises & Plenty on Street

Executive Summary

Appr Church SF
9,390
Appr House SF
2,195
Church property featuring a grand sanctuary with strong character and presence, along with a fully built out second floor previously used for daycare operations. The property includes multiple parish halls, classrooms, and private offices supporting a variety of community or institutional uses.
Additional features include a spacious lower-level hall ideal for events or gatherings, a welcoming entry adjacent to the sanctuary, multiple storage areas, and a children's playground. The site also offers a 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom rectory, providing additional residential or administrative use potential.
Two Parish Halls ~1,600sf, ~900sf
5 Classrooms/ Offices ~200sf - 500sf each

Property Facts

Sale Type Investment or Owner User
Property Type Specialty
Property Subtype Religious Facility
Building Class C
Lot Size 0.56 AC
Building Size 11,585 SF
No. Stories 3
Year Built 1956

Amenities

  • Air Conditioning

Property Taxes

Property Taxes

Parcel Number
2011-33-289-00-0001-0
Land Assessment
$8,644 CAD
Improvements Assessment
$17,027 CAD
Total Assessment
$25,671 CAD
  • Listing ID: 40570777

  • Date on Market: 2026-05-18

  • Last Updated:

  • Address: 33 Jefferson St, Garden City, NY 11530

Link copied
Your LoopNet account has been created!

Please Share Your Feedback

We welcome any feedback on how we can improve LoopNet to better serve your needs.
X
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.starRating, "rating") }}
255 character limit ({{ remainingChars() }} charactercharacters remainingover)
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.msg, "rating") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.fname, "first name") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.lname, "last name") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.phone, "phone number") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.phonex, "phone extension") }}
{{ getErrorText(feedbackForm.email, "email address") }}