Log In/Sign Up
Your email has been sent.
Damato's Seafood 423 Whalley Ave 6 Unit Apartment Building $1,982,616 CAD ($330,436 CAD/Unit) 6.44% Cap Rate New Haven, CT 06511

Investment Highlights
- Prime Location within blocks to Yale and Southern CT University
- Off Street Parking
- Corner lot
Executive Summary
Prime Mixed Use Investment Opportunity in the Heart of New Haven! ***Sale is for the Real Estate only not the business*** Welcome to 423 Whalley Avenue, a well maintained 6 unit mixed use property offering exceptional income potential and strong value add upside. Ideally situated on the corner of Whalley Avenue and Ellsworth Avenue, this 6,100+ sq ft asset features 4 residential apartments and 2 commercial units, currently occupied by the long established Damato's Seafood Restaurant. The residential unit mix includes: * Two (2) - 2BR / 1BA units * One (1) - 3BR / 1BA unit * One (1) - 4BR / 2BA unit (vacant, offering immediate owner user or rent up opportunity) All residential units-aside from the top floor 4BR-are fully occupied, with below market rents providing substantial room for revenue growth. The commercial spaces are fully leased and operating as Damato's Restaurant, a long time neighborhood favorite. Damato's will do a lease back on the space they currently occupy. With a pro forma NOI supporting a potential 7% CAP rate, this property offers both stability and future upside for investors. Additional amenities include a 3 car detached garage, plus a fenced in rear parking lot providing secure parking for tenants and commercial patrons. Whether you're expanding your portfolio or seeking a high performing mixed use asset, 423 Whalley Avenue delivers location, scale, and immediate value add potential in one of New Haven's most active corridors.
Serious inquires only! POF"s or Bank Approval must be presented before any showings. ***Please do not go into the restaurant and ask employees questions***
***The NOI listed is a Pro Forma not Actual**
Serious inquires only! POF"s or Bank Approval must be presented before any showings. ***Please do not go into the restaurant and ask employees questions***
***The NOI listed is a Pro Forma not Actual**
Financial Summary (Pro Forma - 2026) Click Here to Access |
Annual (CAD) | Annual Per SF (CAD) |
|---|---|---|
| Gross Rental Income |
-
|
-
|
| Other Income |
-
|
-
|
| Vacancy Loss |
-
|
-
|
| Effective Gross Income |
$99,999
|
$9.99
|
| Taxes |
$99,999
|
$9.99
|
| Operating Expenses |
$99,999
|
$9.99
|
| Total Expenses |
$99,999
|
$9.99
|
| Net Operating Income |
$99,999
|
$9.99
|
Financial Summary (Pro Forma - 2026) Click Here to Access
| Gross Rental Income (CAD) | |
|---|---|
| Annual | - |
| Annual Per SF | - |
| Other Income (CAD) | |
|---|---|
| Annual | - |
| Annual Per SF | - |
| Vacancy Loss (CAD) | |
|---|---|
| Annual | - |
| Annual Per SF | - |
| Effective Gross Income (CAD) | |
|---|---|
| Annual | $99,999 |
| Annual Per SF | $9.99 |
| Taxes (CAD) | |
|---|---|
| Annual | $99,999 |
| Annual Per SF | $9.99 |
| Operating Expenses (CAD) | |
|---|---|
| Annual | $99,999 |
| Annual Per SF | $9.99 |
| Total Expenses (CAD) | |
|---|---|
| Annual | $99,999 |
| Annual Per SF | $9.99 |
| Net Operating Income (CAD) | |
|---|---|
| Annual | $99,999 |
| Annual Per SF | $9.99 |
Property Facts
Amenities
- Smoke Detector
Unit Amenities
- Air Conditioning
- Heating
- Ceiling Fans
- Eat-in Kitchen
- Kitchen
- Refrigerator
- Oven
- Range
- Family Room
- Large Bedrooms
Site Amenities
- On-Site Retail
- Private Bathroom
Unit Mix Information
| Description | No. Units | Avg. Rent/Mo | SF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3+1 | 1 | - | 950 |
| 2+1 | 2 | - | 950 |
| 4+2 | 1 | - | 1,500 |
1 1
Very walkable
80/100
Exceptionally drivable
90/100
Good public transit
70/100
Moderately bikeable
60/100
Property Taxes
| Parcel Number | NHVN-000333-000294-000100 | Total Assessment | $614,374 CAD (2025) |
| Land Assessment | $125,055 CAD (2025) | Annual Taxes | -$1 CAD ($0.00 CAD/SF) |
| Improvements Assessment | $489,319 CAD (2025) | Tax Year | 2026 Payable 2026 |
Property Taxes
Parcel Number
NHVN-000333-000294-000100
Land Assessment
$125,055 CAD (2025)
Improvements Assessment
$489,319 CAD (2025)
Total Assessment
$614,374 CAD (2025)
Annual Taxes
-$1 CAD ($0.00 CAD/SF)
Tax Year
2026 Payable 2026
1 of 2
Videos
Matterport 3D Exterior
Matterport 3D Tour
Photos
Street View
Street
Map
1 of 1
Presented by
Damato's Seafood | 423 Whalley Ave
Already a member? Log In
Hmm, there seems to have been an error sending your message. Please try again.
Thanks! Your message was sent.
