Convenience Stores For Sale

449 Edwards Ave

Calverton, NY 11933

Convenience Store
Land for Sale
$6,314,700 CAD
12.10 AC Lot

Calverton Land for Sale - Eastern Suffolk

Calling all investors, developers, and end-users to acquire a huge 12.1-acre industrial site. The property features great exposure, excellent signage, 1,000 feet of frontage on the busy Edwards Avenue, strong zoning, upside potential, and more. Located next door to FedEx, other neighbors include Costco, The Home Depot, Target, Walmart, Lowe's, Starbucks, Stop & Shop, Best Buy, CVS, ShopRite, Marshall's, Staples, McDonald's, Wendy's, Taco Bell, Hobby Lobby, Fridays. Nike, the Tanger Outlets, Panera Bread, and so much more. The property is currently home to Long Island's only dirt bike/ ATV track. This could be your next development site/ business location. Inquire today for more information and on-site capabilities.

Contact:

All Island Commercial

Property Subtype:

Industrial

Date on Market:

2021-04-29

Hide

220-226 N. Belle Mead Rd.

Convenience Store
Office for Sale
Price Upon Request
22,456 SF
2 Office Properties

Setauket Portfolio of properties for Sale - Central Suffolk

This is an excellent opportunity to acquire two fully leased Medical office buildings located in the highly desirable Setauket Technology Park. Positioned at 220 N. Belle Mead Avenue and 226 N. Belle Mead Avenue, the portfolio offers stable tenancy, low operating expenses, and exceptional visibility within one of Long Island’s most established medical and technology corridors. 220 N. Belle Mead Avenue totals approximately 11,228 square feet on 1.03 acres with 40 parking spaces. The building is fully leased to Zwanger-Pesiri Radiology, a premier regional medical provider, and the tenant recently executed a brand-new seven-year lease, on their existing lease which has two years remaining, reinforcing their long-term commitment to the site and providing secure, predictable income for an investor. Both properties benefit from tremendous visibility, excellent signage potential, and close proximity to Stony Brook University, Stony Brook University Hospital, and a wide range of major retailers. The location also provides immediate access to key thoroughfares, including Nicolls Road and nearby regional highways, enhancing convenience for tenants and visitors alike. This portfolio is ideal for investors seeking stability, long-term tenancy, and well-positioned medical and professional assets in a high-demand market. 226 N. Belle Mead Avenue presents an excellent opportunity to acquire a fully leased professional and medical office building in the highly desirable Setauket Technology Park. The property consists of approximately 11,228 square feet on 1.10 acres with 44 parking spaces, offering strong visibility, excellent signage potential, and close proximity to Stony Brook University, Stony Brook University Hospital, major retailers, and key regional thoroughfares. The building is occupied by four established tenants, providing diversified income, low operating expenses, and long-term stability for an investor. The tenancy includes Just Cats in Suite A under a long-term lease through 2034, responsible for 22.7 percent of CAM charges, real estate taxes, and insurance, with 3 percent rent increases every three years. OneHealth Pharmacy occupies Suite B on a year-to-year basis and pays its proportionate share of CAM charges, real estate taxes, and insurance, with 2.5 percent annual increases. New York Cancer & Blood Specialists occupies Suite C under a lease running through 2032 and is responsible for 50.9 percent of CAM charges, real estate taxes, and insurance, with 2.5 percent annual increases. Envision Marketing occupies the garage space under an annual renewal structure, with utilities included in rent. Together, these tenants create a stable, diversified rent roll with minimal landlord responsibilities.

Contact:

Douglas Elliman Commercial

Date on Market:

2026-04-09

Hide

359 Route 111

Smithtown, NY 11787

Convenience Store
Office for Sale
Price Upon Request
9,000 SF

24 Hour Access

Smithtown Office for Sale - Western Suffolk

Contact Exclusive Listing Associate Broker for Details::: HOOTAN MOEIRZADEH - (516) 441-2646 (Mobile) Hootan.Moeirzadeh@elliman.com MIKE LIGHTCAP MOBILE: 631.445.5756 Mike.Lightcap@elliman.com _________________________________________________ Welcome to: 359 Route 111, Smithtown, NY 11787 AVAILABLE for SALE Now! 3 x 3,000ft NEWLY Renovated Buildings with 50-60+/- Parking Spaces *Newly listed all details will be posted asap. _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Contact Exclusive Listing Broker to Excellent opportunity to purchase medical or professional office buildings,. This property consists of three freestanding 3,000-square-foot buildings situated on a 1.00-acre lot, offering a rare chance for an investor to acquire a well-located asset with significant value-add potential through renovations, repositioning, and targeted lease-up strategies. Strategically located in Smithtown on heavily traveled 359 Route 111 (Hauppauge Road) with 141 feet of frontage, the site offers exceptional convenience to Route 347, Veterans Highway, the Northern State Parkway, and other major thoroughfares. Positioned near the Hauppauge border and surrounded by both local and national retailers, the location provides strong visibility and accessibility. The property is in close proximity to major medical institutions, including St. Catherine’s (Catholic Health Services) and renowned Stony Brook Hospital. Additional highlights include parking for 54 vehicles, marquee signage, and tremendous exposure within an exceptional demographic. This is an ideal opportunity for an investor seeking a value-add medical or professional office asset in a high-demand market. _______________________________________________________________________ Schedule A Private Showing Please contact the exclusive Agent(s) HOOTAN MOEIRZADEH - (516) 441-2646 (Mobile) Hootan.Moeirzadeh@elliman.com MIKE LIGHTCAP MOBILE: 631.445.5756 Mike.Lightcap@elliman.com

Contact:

NY Real Estate - HootanRE

Property Subtype:

Medical

Date on Market:

2026-04-06

Hide

41 E Main St

Riverhead, NY 11901

Convenience Store
Retail for Sale
Price Upon Request
4,000 SF

Riverhead Retail for Sale - Eastern Suffolk

Prime opportunity to purchase a two-story mixed-use building in the heart of Main Street, Riverhead. The first floor ±1,950 SF retail storefront is currently vacant and available for lease, offering strong visibility and a flexible layout suitable for a variety of retail or service-based uses. The second floor includes ±1,950 SF of office space, fully occupied by two tenants, providing stable income for an owner-user or investor. Positioned directly in front of Peconic Riverfront Park, the property offers alleyway access to the municipal parking lot and the waterfront, creating a unique blend of exposure and convenience. Ample street parking and nearby municipal options support steady customer and employee access. The location is just minutes from Old Country Road and Riverhead’s major shopping district, benefiting from consistent foot traffic and strong downtown activity. With its central location, adaptable floor plans, and proximity to key amenities, this property presents an exceptional opportunity for both owner-users and investors seeking a presence in one of Long Island’s most active downtown corridors. Ideal for end user/investor.

Contact:

Douglas Elliman Commercial

Property Subtype:

Storefront Retail/Office

Date on Market:

2026-03-18

Hide

More details for 535 Middle Country Rd, Saint James, NY - Retail for Sale

Turn-Key Auto Showroom & Service Center - 535 Middle Country Rd

Saint James, NY 11780

Convenience Store
Retail for Sale
Price Upon Request
36,310 SF

Saint James Retail for Sale - Western Suffolk

535 Middle Country Road is a showroom and service center ideal for owner-users. It offers over 36,000 square feet of building area across two stories on approximately 2.5 acres, and it will be delivered vacant, providing flexibility for various operations. The lot features multiple roll-up gates and ingress/egress points, making it suitable for any automotive use. Located at a prime corner signalized intersection on Middle Country Road, within an automotive corridor with around 300 feet of frontage, it offers excellent visibility and brand exposure. This highly trafficked location is surrounded by national retailers such as BMW, Honda, Volkswagen, Mercedes, Volvo, Lincoln, Ford, CarMax, Dairy Queen, and Wendy’s, ensuring high traffic and prominent exposure. Contact exclusive brokers for more information or to arrange for a property inspection.

Contact:

Ripco Real Estate

Property Subtype:

Auto Dealership

Date on Market:

2026-02-25

Hide

200 Nicolls Rd

Stony Brook, NY 11790

Convenience Store
Office for Sale
Price Upon Request
11,000 SF

Stony Brook Office for Sale - Central Suffolk

Excellent opportunity on Nicolls Road (County Road 97) in Stony Brook, offering exceptional visibility and direct access along one of Suffolk County’s most traveled corridors. Situated just minutes from Stony Brook University and the renowned Stony Brook University Hospital, this +/- 11,000 SF office building provides an ideal setting for professional or medical office users seeking a prime location with strong regional connectivity. Positioned on a larger 39-acre site, the property benefits from expansive surroundings and a highly strategic location within a major institutional and medical corridor. With over 24,000 vehicles passing daily, the building enjoys outstanding exposure and signage potential along this key north–south artery. The 10,000 SF structure offers a versatile layout suitable for a wide range of professional, clinical, or administrative uses. Ample on-site parking for more than 50 vehicles ensures convenience for staff, patients, and visitors. Whether pursued as a purchase or a lease opportunity, this property delivers a compelling combination of location, accessibility, and long-term growth potential in one of Long Island’s most sought-after commercial corridors.

Contact:

Douglas Elliman Commercial

Date on Market:

2026-02-10

Hide

225-227 Union Ave

Convenience Store
Mixed Types for Sale
Price Upon Request
2 Properties | Mixed Types

Holbrook Portfolio of properties for Sale - Central Suffolk

An exceptional opportunity to acquire a two-building portfolio situated on a combined 0.79 acres in the heart of Holbrook. This rare offering includes a three-bedroom, two-bath legal residential rental home and a 6,910 SF professional/medical office building, formerly the well-known Sachem Animal Hospital. The J2-zoned professional building features multiple entrances, a flexible layout, oil and gas heat, ample on-site parking, strong visibility, and a partial basement with exterior access. The building also includes a freshly painted one-bedroom apartment above, creating an additional income stream or on-site operational convenience. The site benefits from tremendous frontage and a double-sided marquee sign, maximizing exposure for any commercial or medical user. The accompanying three-bedroom, two-bath home is uniquely positioned with mixed J2 and residential zoning, allowing it to function as a legal residential rental or be repurposed for business use, offering exceptional flexibility. The home includes new siding and fresh paint, hardwood and carpet throughout, new Frigidaire appliances, gas heat, a full basement with interior and exterior entrances, a detached one-car garage with ample storage, and a fully fenced yard, enhancing both usability and tenant appeal. The property’s strategic location offers outstanding regional connectivity. It is just minutes from the Station Yards at the Ronkonkoma LIRR and provides easy access to the Long Island Expressway, Sunrise Highway, and other major transportation routes, strengthening both user convenience and long-term investment performance. This portfolio represents an incredible opportunity for an end user, investor, or operator seeking a versatile, well-positioned asset with significant upside potential.

Contact:

Douglas Elliman Commercial

Property Subtype:

Mixed Types

Date on Market:

2026-02-09

Hide

4 Building's & 3 Restaurants Available

Convenience Store
Mixed Types for Sale
Price Upon Request
4 Properties | Mixed Types

Bay Shore Portfolio of properties for Sale - Southwestern Suffolk

THE FOUR BUILDINGS & THE 3 RESTAURANTS ARE OFFERED AS A PORTFOLIO TOGETHER. EACH RESTAUANT CAN ALSO BE PURCHASED & LEASED SEPRATELY 3 of these properties have a ground floor restaurant spaces which includes 19 West Main St 1600 sq. ft., 1 West Main St. the corner of Main St and Fourth Ave 2400 sq. ft., and 10-12 Fourth Ave 3500 sq. ft. The restaurants are being offered as a purchase and lease call the listing agent for more info 516 819 6951. The three restaurants can be leased and purchased, key money required, together or separately. This portfolio would be perfect for a restaurant tour that would like to operate the three restaurants as part of the existing portfolio we have included photos of the interiors of the restaurants for your convenience. The four properties for sale are in the heart of Downtown Bay Shore intersecting Main St., 27A, Montauk Hwy and Fourth Ave also known as Maple Ave South of Montauk Hwy., 1-3 Main St., & 2-6 Fourth Ave located on the NW Corner and 2 & 4 West Main St are situated on the SW Corner are some of the most visible properties located in Downtown Bay Shore with heavy traffic passing East and West and North to South with a high volume of foot traffic. Bay Shore has become the Jewel of the South Shore with thousands of apartments built over the years and more coming . Main St has become restaurant and retail row with the Boulton Theatre providing all venues of entertainment. Fourth Ave also known as Maple Ave is the gateway to the Ferry Terminal to Fire Island with visitors from all over the world passing these properties and patronaging the Downtown on their way to Fire Island. Bay Shore has grown to be one of Long Island most desirable communities to live and work and is still expanding and growing with more to come. Visit Bay Shore, patronize our restaurants, theaters, and shopping. A short walk from the train station to downtown. Property 1 - #1-3 Main St, 2-6 Fourth Ave Bay Shore NY 11706 Mixed Use Property Ground floor commercial consisting of #1 West Main St Restaurant The Corner #3 West Main St rented to a travel agency #4 Fourth Ave rented as Salon # 6 Fourth Ave rented as Barber Shop 2 Fourth Ave., 10 Apartments rented on 2nd and 3rd Floor Property 2 - #19 West Main St Bay Shore NY 11706 Rented as a restaurant Property 3 - #10-12 Fourth Ave Bay Shore NY 11706 Rented as Restaurant 1 apartment above Property 4 - 2-4 West Main St # 2 West Main St rented as Optometrist # 2 West Main St upper level offices # 4 West Main St Offices

Contact:

Reality Rental

Property Subtype:

Mixed Types

Date on Market:

2023-11-13

Hide

More details for 217 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY - Land for Sale

217 Middle Country Road, Middle Island, NY - 217 Middle Country Rd

Middle Island, NY 11953

Convenience Store
Land for Sale
$916,650 CAD
1.77 AC Lot

Middle Island Land for Sale - Central Suffolk

Brand New State-of-the-Art Medical Building Available and Shove Ready, All Permits in Place! Discover the pinnacle of modern medical facilities at our new location on Rt 25A, where over 25,000 cars pass by daily. Enjoy easy access and ample parking in a prime location designed for your convenience. Our building features high-efficiency green construction, ensuring a sustainable and comfortable environment. We offer customizable configurations tailored to accommodate a variety of medical practices.

Contact:

Coldwell Banker Commercial AMH

Property Subtype:

Commercial

Date on Market:

2026-02-26

Hide

More details for 846-900 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, Middle Island, NY - Retail for Sale

Middle Island Plaza - 846-900 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island

Middle Island, NY 11953

Convenience Store
Retail for Sale
$23,765,001 CAD
86,118 SF

Middle Island Retail for Sale - Central Suffolk

American Investment Properties is retained to sell the property located at 846-900 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island. At this location is a large retail neighborhood center consisting of several tenants. Most tenants are on long-term leases with options to extend. There are currently 2 vacant spaces that provide for great lease-up opportunities. This property has vast frontage on Middle Country Rd and ample on-site parking for the convenience of shoppers.

Contact:

American Investment Properties, Inc.

Property Subtype:

Storefront

Date on Market:

2026-02-12

Hide

967 Sunrise Hwy

West Babylon, NY 11704

Convenience Store
Land for Sale
$475,300 CAD
0.18 AC Lot

West Babylon Land for Sale - Southwestern Suffolk

Investment-Grade Land in West Babylon – 967 Sunrise Hwy Discover a rare opportunity to acquire an infill lot of approximately 7,896 sq ft (0.18 acre) on the service road of the prominent Sunrise Hwy corridor in West Babylon (11704). This cleared, level parcel offers frontage of approximately 100 ft and presents a prime canvas for a custom luxury residence, multi-unit infill, or strategic buy-and-hold land play. Located in the thriving suburbs of the Town of Babylon, this site combines commuter convenience, strong local fundamentals, and tangible value-add potential. Close to highways, local retail and services, and within a top-tier school zone, this is a smart move for the astute builder or investor. current market data suggests materially higher valuation for comparable land. Don’t miss this chance to secure a strategic land position in one of Long Island’s high-demand communities. Contact us today for full due-diligence package (zoning, utilities, entitlements) and to structure terms that fit your investment timeline.

Contact:

eXp Realty

Property Subtype:

Residential

Date on Market:

2025-11-06

Hide

504 Fire Island Ave

Babylon, NY 11702

Convenience Store
Flex for Sale
$1,561,700 CAD
5,801 SF

Babylon Flex for Sale - Southwestern Suffolk

Mixed-Use Investment Opportunity in the Heart of Babylon Village! Prime Babylon Village location featuring two income-producing commercial spaces on the first level—both leased through mid 2028—plus two residential apartments above. The first-floor apartment offers 2 bedrooms, while the second floor features a spacious 3-bedroom unit. Additional income potential with two detached garages and 100 feet of rentable bulkhead. Tenants and deli enjoy private off-street parking, a rare convenience in the Village. Taxes: Town of Babylon: $16,649.85 Babylon Village: $1,918.35 An exceptional opportunity to own a well-maintained, income-generating property in one of Long Island’s most desirable downtowns!

Contact:

The Agency

Date on Market:

2025-10-20

Hide

20 Sunken Meadow Rd

Northport, NY 11768

Convenience Store
Land for Sale
$2,709,210 CAD
5.57 AC Lot

Northport Land for Sale - Western Suffolk

We are pleased to present a unique and rare development opportunity located in the prestigious area of Northport, NY. This expansive 5.57-acre property is strategically nestled within the center of highly sought-after neighborhood of Northport bordering Fort Salonga and Kings Park, all within the municipality of Smithtown. The property is situated in the well-regarded Kings Park School District. This lushly wooded parcel offers an unparalleled opportunity for developers to create an exclusive enclave of 4 to 5 luxury single-family homes. The serene and picturesque setting provides a perfect canvas for a high-end residential development, catering to discerning buyers seeking privacy and tranquility. The property's prime location ensures convenient access to a wealth of amenities and attractions. It is in close proximity to Huntington Village, renowned for its vibrant shopping and dining scene, as well as major thoroughfares, making commuting and travel effortless. Additionally, the area boasts a variety of cultural and recreational facilities, including museums, historic sites, parks, and beautiful North Shore beaches. Healthcare needs are well-served with several top-tier hospitals nearby. This development site offers the perfect blend of luxury, convenience, and natural beauty, making it an exceptional investment opportunity!

Contact:

Douglas Elliman Commercial

Property Subtype:

Residential

Date on Market:

2025-03-07

Hide

More details for 1032 Portion Rd, Farmingville, NY - Retail for Sale

Former Farmingville Dairy Barn For Sale - 1032 Portion Rd

Farmingville, NY 11738

Convenience Store
Retail for Sale
$1,222,200 CAD
1,038 SF

Farmingville Retail for Sale - Central Suffolk

Located on busy Portion Road and the corner of Warren Street, this former Dairy Barn property would be perfect for an owner / operator of a convenience store, coffee shop, food use, or tobacco shop. The property currently has a double drive thru lane. Contact an SRG agent for more information on this opportunity.

Contact:

Sovereign Realty Group

Property Subtype:

Convenience

Date on Market:

2023-03-27

Hide

More details for 1 Main St, Center Moriches, NY - Retail for Sale

Former Center Moriches Dairy Barn For Sale - 1 Main St

Center Moriches, NY 11934

Convenience Store
Retail for Sale
$1,290,100 CAD
1,298 SF

Center Moriches Retail for Sale - Eastern Suffolk

Former Diary Barn convenience store with a double drive-thru. Located at the traffic light regulated corner of Lake Avenue. Located across from Center Moriches Square. Perfect for a user / investor.

Contact:

Sovereign Realty Group

Property Subtype:

Convenience

Date on Market:

2023-03-14

Hide

Land for Sale and Lease

Convenience Store
Land for Sale
Price Upon Request
0.73 AC
2 Land Properties

Portfolio of properties for Sale - Eastern Suffolk

These land lots are available for both lease and sale.

Contact:

Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life

Date on Market:

2025-11-04

Hide

1841 New York Ave

Huntington Station, NY 11746

Convenience Store
Office for Sale
Price Upon Request
9,000 SF

Air Conditioning
Security System

Huntington Station Office for Sale - Western Suffolk

10,000± square foot office complex is prominently located on heavily trafficked New York Avenue, offering excellent visibility and accessibility in the heart of Huntington. Situated on a 0.31-acre lot, the property includes a gated rear area with approximately 22 parking spaces, providing both convenience and security for staff and visitors. The building underwent a comprehensive renovation in 2009. The main level spans approximately 4,777 square feet and features 11 private offices, three support rooms, a large conference room, reception area, two restrooms, a service elevator, and a 12-foot overhead door—well suited for businesses requiring light distribution or equipment access. The lower level offers an additional 4,223 square feet and includes five private offices, a fully equipped TV/media studio, two flexible-use rooms, a large bathroom, two waiting areas, an open bullpen workspace, and a kitchenette with a lounge area. This layout makes the property highly adaptable to a wide range of professional uses. Ideal for production or recording studios, creative agencies, law firms, design or architecture practices, or a company headquarters, the building’s location is just minutes from the Huntington LIRR station and is surrounded by national retailers. With easy access to major roadways and commuter routes, this property offers a strategic setting for businesses seeking visibility and convenience

Contact:

Douglas Elliman Commercial

Property Subtype:

Medical

Date on Market:

2025-07-08

Hide

More details for 623-647 Grand blvd, Deer Park, NY - Land for Sale

Prime Residential Development Opportunity - 623-647 Grand blvd

Deer Park, NY 11729

Convenience Store
Land for Sale
Price Upon Request
3.18 AC Lot

Deer Park Land for Sale - Western Suffolk

Located in the highly desirable Deer Park community, this offering includes three residentially zoned parcels spanning 3.18 acres, making it a prime opportunity for residential development. With ample space to accommodate growing housing demand, this expansive property is perfectly suited for a thoughtfully designed community or private estate. Positioned for convenience and accessibility, it enjoys close proximity to major roadways, public transportation, and essential amenities, ensuring an attractive lifestyle for future residents. The combination of favorable zoning, a sought-after location, and strong market demand makes this an exceptional investment. Seize the chance to develop in one of Deer Park’s most promising residential areas—a rare opportunity not to be missed!

Contact:

Douglas Elliman Commercial

Property Subtype:

Residential

Date on Market:

2025-02-16

Hide