Oak Knolls Manor - 3956 Caledonia Avon Rd

Caledonia, NY 14423

• Motel
• Specialty for Sale
• $2,066,970 CAD
• 13,400 SF

• Air Conditioning
• Wheelchair Accessible

Caledonia Specialty for Sale

A unique opportunity to own a piece of history. Oak Knolls Manor is an elegant country estate situated on 5 acres of land surrounded by hundreds of acres of tillable farmland and wooded land that provide views of the Genesee Valley that simply cannot be found elsewhere. The property includes a 3,400 square foot fully restored Federal Colonial farmhouse and a famous custom-built Wells Barn. The barn was built in 1893 by J. T. Wells and Sons and is one of only approximately 40 barns left in the United States still standing from the original 100 barns that were raised. This turn-key operation includes a well-established business and meticulously maintained real estate. Oak Knolls Manor, an elegant country event venue, is for sale as a complete package. Positioned as a high-end full-service venue, it hosts one event per week. Since 2018, its reputation has been built on style, class, and hospitality.

Contact:

Benchmark Realty Advisors

Property Subtype:

Lodge/Meeting Hall

Date on Market:

2026-05-04

Hide

See More

4647 Reservoir Rd

Geneseo, NY 14454

• Motel
• Specialty for Sale
• $790,961 CAD
• 7,200 SF

Geneseo Specialty for Sale - Livingston County

Have you priced out what it costs to build 7,000+ square feet with infrastructure and parking today? You’re looking at a property that skips that entire process. This 7,200 SF commercial building sits on nearly 4 acres in Geneseo, NY and delivers something that’s increasingly hard to find: scale, flexibility, and immediate usability at a price far below replacement cost. Originally designed for assembly use, the building offers: Large open gathering areas Multiple private offices or rooms Strong natural light throughout Flexible layout for single or multi-tenant use This makes it ideal for: Professional office or headquarters Medical, wellness, or therapy center Event or wedding venue Daycare or educational facility Community or religious use Live/work or adaptive residential conversion (subject to approvals) The site is equally compelling. With nearly 4 acres and 40 on-site parking spaces, the property supports high-traffic operations, events, or future expansion. From an investment standpoint, this is a rare adaptive reuse opportunity in a market with limited large-format inventory. Whether you operate it as-is, reposition it, or redevelop portions of the site, the infrastructure already in place would be costly and time-consuming to replicate today. Additional highlights: Freestanding building with strong presence Approved road access with future entrance off North Rd Utilities being separated for standalone functionality Potential for zoning modification (buyer to verify) For operators, investors, or developers looking for scale and flexibility, this is a high-upside commercial asset with multiple paths to value creation.

Contact:

Real Broker NY LLC

Property Subtype:

Lodge/Meeting Hall

Date on Market:

2026-05-03

Hide

See More

490 Motel - 360 Mount Read Blvd

Rochester, NY 14611

• Motel
• Hospitality for Sale
• $3,169,354 CAD
• 14,902 SF

Rochester Hospitality for Sale - Greater Rochester

Established Motel with 28 Rooms on high visibility corner. Plenty of parking. Business does not convey. All Leaseholds and equipment conveys as is.

Contact:

Empire Realty Group

Property Subtype:

Hotel

Date on Market:

2025-09-22

Hide

See More

Air B&B, Cabins and RV - 984 Waterloo Geneva Rd

Waterloo Town, NY 13165

• Motel
• Specialty for Sale
• $819,898 CAD
• 1,000 SF

• Waterfront

Waterloo Town Specialty for Sale

984 Waterloo Geneva Road | Waterloo, NY Incredible Mixed-Use Investment with Water Access Turnkey Income + Expansion Potential Retail Building (2,400 sq ft): Currently leased at $1,500/month 5 Log Cabins (12’ x 20’ each): One fully renovated; four in progress—buyer can complete or seller will finish Additional Sites: 6 more pads ready for tiny homes or RV rentals Waterfront Perks 133 ft on the Cayuga-Seneca Canal Private Dock: Multiple boat slips—ideal for short-term rental appeal Public Utilities: Sewer, water, electric & high-speed internet—year-round functionality Multiple Revenue Streams Retail, short-term rentals (Airbnb/Vacasa), RV sites, or seasonal family compound Expandable footprint on 1.54 acres along highly trafficked Hwy 5 & 20 Investor-Friendly Terms 10% cap rate guaranteed by seller (Year 1) Owner financing available to qualified buyers Prime Location High-visibility corridor near Finger Lakes attractions, wineries & lakeside towns

Contact:

Coldwell Banker Prime Properties

Property Subtype:

Trailer/Camper Park

Date on Market:

2025-07-15

Hide

See More

270 Lake St

Penn Yan, NY 14527

• Motel
• Office for Sale
• $1,784,484 CAD
• 19,752 SF

Penn Yan Office for Sale

Great Opportunity for Investor looking for a Finger Lakes Region Asset at the N.E. end of Keuka Lake in the Village of Penn Yan Commercial District. Located across from the Hampton Inn and Knapp & Schlappi Lumber Yard. The Gross Bldg. Area is 21,227 SF is situated on 2.4 acres offering 65 parking spaces. It is Zoned General Commercial. A mix of Professional Office, Wellness Services and Retail Services-it is a well-cared for Building with updated infrastructure. Offering a Net Operating Income of $105,300/yr.

Contact:

RE/MAX 1st Commercial

Date on Market:

2025-06-02

Hide

See More

Build to Suit / Lease or Own - 1220 Commercial Dr

Farmington, NY 14425

• Motel
• Land for Sale
• $117,128 CAD
• 0.95 AC Lot

Farmington Land for Sale - Outlying Ontario County

On Commercial Drive off Route 96. Ideal 1 acre parcel for restaurant, bank, retail location on flat, readily usable terrain. DiFelice Development, Inc. offers this lot as both sale or lease opportunities and is ready to Build to Suit. Lease rates dependent on tenant parameters. On corner of State Route 96. Quarter mile from intersection of 332 and adjacent to Comfort Inn. Two miles from NYS Thruway exit 44. Four miles to village of Victor. Highly desirable location, highly trafficked Route 96.

Contact:

DiFelice Development, Inc

Property Subtype:

Commercial

Date on Market:

2016-09-13

Hide

See More

Corner Routes 332 + 96 Adjacent to McDonalds - 1200 State Route 332

Farmington, NY 14425

• Motel
• Land for Sale
• $3,031,556 CAD
• 18 AC Lot

Farmington Land for Sale - Outlying Ontario County

DiFelice Development's parcel offers access to both State Route 96 and State Route 332. Next door to McDonalds and gas station, less than one mile from NYS Thruway exit 44. On west side of State Route 332. Seven miles to Eastview Mall and three miles to Village of Victor. Flat, highly visible terrain. Access to both State Route 96 and State Route 332. Just north of McDonalds and large signalized intersection. Adjacent 2 acres are also available. See image for details. Retail plaza across street including CVS and Finger Lakes Coffee Roasters. Aldi, Dunkin Donuts, KFC and Comfort Inn in immediate vicinity. Annual average daily traffic per 2018 NYS DOT of 21,717.

Contact:

DiFelice Development, Inc

Property Subtype:

Commercial

Date on Market:

2006-05-05

Hide

See More

111 Room Motel Henrietta OFFERS ACCEPTED NOW - 4853 W Henrietta Rd

Henrietta, NY 14467

• Motel
• Hospitality for Sale
• $3,444,950 CAD
• 52,182 SF

• Restaurant

Henrietta Hospitality for Sale - South Central

Rare opportunity to acquire a 109 room NON PERFORMING motel at a WHOLESALE PRICE with long term leased restaurant on 6.15 acres well located in vibrant Henrietta NY at the crossroads of the NY Thruway and interstate 390 , just 10 minutes from Rochester Institute of Technology. Outstanding opportunity for redevelopment as a hotel , housing or mixed use retail. The motel can be repositioned with the requisite capital investment , there are financial incentives available from several franchises which makes this option attractive. Assumable loan .

Contact:

John P Christopher

Property Subtype:

Hotel

Date on Market:

2025-08-24

Hide

See More