Commercial Real Estate in Cooperstown available for sale
Cooperstown Motels For Sale

Motels for Sale within 50 kilometers of Cooperstown, NY, USA

More details for 5 Prospect St, Little Falls, NY - Specialty for Sale

Masonic Lodge - 5 Prospect St

Little Falls, NY 13365

  • Motel
  • Specialty for Sale
  • $688,852 CAD
  • 16,960 SF

Little Falls Specialty for Sale - Herkimer County

Step back in time...specifically 1914...and immerse yourself in a place of mystery and ...magnificence... A grand building...Where we can imagine the secret meetings, voices, and music that once echoed in the halls. Step inside one of the few modern monoliths that remain standing firm...of the Masonic Lodge. Setting majestically on the corner of Prospect and School streets, in the historic City of Little Falls New York, this French Gothic Castle is striking with its back drop of the Mohawk River and the Valley hilltops. Architect William Neil Smith…cited the French Medieval Period as his inspiration for the magnificent structure. The building style was based on the ‘unusual character of the land plot’ donated by Major Sponable, a Civil War hero, who became a Mason on Oct. 26, 1854...on a hillside overlooking the Mohawk Valley. The building is constructed of brick and stone with French Medieval half timber work and cement stucco. The framing is a combination of wood and Steel beams, the latter used to support the wider spans and heavier weight loads associated with the larger rooms in the building. The main roof and roofs of the two towers are red terra cotta tile flashed with copper. Originally the building contained the following rooms for use by the members of the Masonic Organization: Lower level contained a Bowling Alley with two large lanes accessed by the separate entrance from the School Street. The first floor contained the social and club rooms accessible through the tower at the intersection of school and prospect streets. The second floor is accessed by the large double doors on prospect street and was called the ‘Commandery Floor’. The Second floor contains a kitchen, ballroom with bar, and a stage. The room measures a massive 27 by 67 feet. The foyer of the second floor boasts a large staircase which leads to the Mezzanine Level, containing the original dressing rooms, coat rooms, and Lockers for the Masonic activities. The top floor contains the Lodge Room measuring 61 by 37 feet, and is finished in the English Medieval Renaissance Period. The Lodge room contains an operating Pipe Organ situated in an organ loft on the western end of the room. One can imagine the chills and goosebumps in this space that allows sound waves to reflect on the walls and bounce around as they amplify the effects. Over the years the building has been utilized for other purposes including: a nursery school, pottery and art studio, dance and music practice and presentations, elegant events, and as a magnificent living space. The property was owned by terry tippin and used as a personal home and studio from 1995 to 2021 upon which The Staywell Properties took possession. The Masons met here until 2004 when they merged with the Dolgeville Masons courtesy of the then owner, Mrs. Tippin. In its ‘heyday’ there were 350 Masons and the 173 members of the Order of the Eastern Star. With Over 12,000 square feet of interior space, the sky really is the limit on the elevated living spaces and, the creative and imaginative, entrepreneurial spirit of the inhabitants. The current owners have invested a significant investment into the property and taken the potential of what could be created, to a whole new level! On the main level, an incredible bar was installed with the vision of a space that can host elegant affairs. A 150 thousand dollar screen projection system was installed to offer full motion picture, professional licensed current content. Custom ballroom curtains with materials ordered from France adorn the space. A full level of the castle offers living quarters. Much of the custom kitchen is already installed. 2 bedrooms and grand, personal entertaining rooms boast soaring ceilings and magnificent views. There is an abundance of building materials on site that will convey to the next owner to complete the vision. A total of 4 parcels will convey with this extraordinary property. A bound information book will be provided to all potential buyers at private showings. Bring your imagination and watch what unfolds in front of you!

Contact:

River Hills Properties

Property Subtype:

Lodge/Meeting Hall

Date on Market:

2025-08-07

Hide
See More
More details for 102 Main St, Jefferson, NY - Hospitality for Sale

The Mill Pond Inn & Tavern - 102 Main St

Jefferson, NY 12093

  • Motel
  • Hospitality for Sale
  • $1,791,374 CAD
  • 4,900 SF

Jefferson Hospitality for Sale - Schoharie County

Welcome to The Mill Pond Inn & Tavern - an iconic, historic property steeped in character and charm, in the heart of Jefferson, NY. Originally built in 1879 as a grain and saw mill, this landmark was meticulously and lovingly restored in 2018, preserving its rich history and details, while updating every system from the studs out. Set on the picturesque Mill Pond, the property offers a unique combination of hospitality, history, and opportunity. The spacious main dining room and event space accommodates up to 100 guests, with an additional 42 seats and additional bar on the expansive deck overlooking the pond. A separate tavern area provides cozy seating for 31 and the seasonal Carriage House seats 75-100 and features a wood/gas-fired pizza oven and full bar, making it an ideal setting for weddings, live music, private events and pizza nights. The second floor is home to the Inn, featuring five guest suites with private baths, each thoughtfully designed to reflect the property's rich heritage and character. A dedicated laundry and service room adds convenience for housekeeping. With a scenic walking path complete with a waterfall encircling the pond and tranquil water views from every dining area, The Mill Pond Inn & Tavern is a true destination in Upstate New York. The property offers ample parking with 100 spaces, plus additional staff parking, and is fully operational with an established and loyal local following. This is a rare opportunity for new owners to easily step in and continue, or further expand this thriving business. Located in Jefferson, recently added to the National Register of Historic Places, this bucolic village draws visitors year-round. Whether catering to skiers, hikers, baseball enthusiasts heading to nearby Cooperstown, or city dwellers in search of a quintessential upstate experience, this property offers endless potential for expansion into weddings, retreats, and destination events. This is an established business with strong repeat clientele, quality staff and limited competition. A turnkey, historic landmark in an unbeatable setting -The Mill Pond Inn & Tavern is ready to write its next chapter with you. Additional adjacent 50 acre developable land parcel as well as "the Parsonage House" available for interested parties as a separate offering.

Contact:

The Catskill Dream Team

Property Subtype:

Hotel

Date on Market:

2025-06-18

Hide
See More
More details for 2-8 W Main St, Little Falls, NY - Multifamily for Sale

Snyder Building/Staywell Property - 2-8 W Main St

Little Falls, NY 13365

  • Motel
  • Multifamily for Sale
  • $378,944 CAD
  • 31,104 SF
  • Security System
  • 24 Hour Access
  • Controlled Access
  • Smoke Detector

Little Falls Multifamily for Sale - Herkimer County

What if you were presented with a blank canvas to launch your next adventure …. a property located within the heart of Central NY …in the Little Falls Downtown Historic District…a city located an equal distance between the two metropolitan hubs of Albany and Syracuse. What type of project would you create? Perhaps… a multi-family luxury lofts/apartments project, an entertainment venue, a specialty business venture, medical/professional offices, a hotel, a restaurant? but definitely…a mixed-use commercial property. The sky really is the limit! Let me introduce you to 2 West Main Street… Your blank canvas! This intriguing redevelopment opportunity is centered on one of the most prominent streets within the city of Little Falls …Main Street USA!!! This area is an up-and-coming mix-use destination filled with dining, taverns, antique shopping, cafes, coffee shops, florists, specialty gift shops…and the center for notable annual festivals. The City of Little Falls is steeped in Central New York History and was once a major industrial center. Many of the magnificent masonry buildings fortunately, remain in the area, just waiting to be repurposed, and re imagined. Notably known as ‘The Snyder Building’, the structure was set up as 40 apartments with a regal entrance, the likes seen in Manhattan. There are 7 storefronts…2 with long term tenants and the others awaiting reimagination. The building is set up as follows: 7 storefronts on the main level…4 floors of 10 apartments each…and the top floor open. There is a basement in this building holding additional storage space and utility placements. The sellers of the building had a vision of creating 6 luxury condos within the 4 story apartment spaces, a conference, or ballroom on the top level and fully functional commercial options on the main level. The views from the building windows are incredible! Unfortunately, unforeseen turn of events occurred, and the construction had to be halted. Currently, the building is mostly gutted, but prepared for a new vision by the next owner. In December 2021, Little Falls was selected to receive $10 million in grant funding to implement transformative capital projects in its downtown area as part of Round Five of the Downtown Revitalization Initiative (DRI). The DRI is a New York State grant program designed to catalyze public and private investment in urban centers with significant opportunities for redevelopment, business growth, job creation, and an improved quality of life for all. Little Falls’ DRI will focus on reconnecting its Downtown Main Street to its waterfront along the Mohawk River and historic Canal District. As the only city in Herkimer County, Little Falls envisions itself as the most desirable residential community in the region by reconnecting isolated parts of the city to create a single, cohesive downtown district. The City has experienced approximately $11.6 million in recent and ongoing investments and anticipates another $76.8 million in the future. These investments include new apartment housing, a bourbon distilling site, and a proposed new train station providing passenger service. Building on this momentum, Little Falls aims to us the DRI to diversify housing, improve multi-modal connectivity, and enhance the quality of life for all residents. As a mixed commercial area, creative minded developers are sought to purchase and redevelop this 46,000 plus, Sq. foot building with its 6 stories of mostly open space and high ceilings. This property offers gas, sewer and electric utilities, oversized openings, and elevator shaft in place. Originally built in the late 1920’s for hotel, living and commercial spaces, much of the existing infrastructure may be re-utilized, depending on the project. The seller has done extensive work on the building to ensure structural stability. The city of Little Falls is committed to streamlining the approval process for developers, encouraging creative design, and looking for ways to incentivize investment in the area. 2 to 8 west main street sets close to the numerous city parks and the Vibrant Canal Park community which also boasts: The Canal Side Inn, The Inn at Stone Mill, and the Antique Center. Little Falls is a very walkable community with an award-winning school system and an abundance of shopping and cultural events. Developers are already taking notice of the district’s proximity to existing and future attractions and have launched several projects nearby. Central New York is ripe for big things to happen, and the momentum has started 20 minutes down the road in Utica! The new MVHS Hospital opens soon, Wolfspeed has built their facility on one of 3 ‘shovel ready’ chip sites, NANO…and the ancillary businesses associated with this growth are here! With a strong interest in the revitalizing of Little Falls, properties like the Snyder Building will not stay on the market long. Bring your vision to Historic Little Falls New York and develop a memorable legacy for the future generations to enjoy. Text or Call Robin Mongeau of River Hills Properties, LLC today and learn more about this exciting redevelopment opportunity. Check out our Asteroom link detailing the floor plans of the building. https://www.asteroom.com/pviewer?hideleadgen=1&token=V2HcCJB-YkOLlWlvgMwbhA

Contact:

River Hills Properties

Property Subtype:

Apartment

Date on Market:

2024-05-03

Hide
See More
More details for 304 Sutherland Rd, East Meredith, NY - Specialty for Sale

Natural Gardens - 304 Sutherland Rd

East Meredith, NY 13757

  • Motel
  • Specialty for Sale
  • $6,821,001 CAD
  • 12,500 SF
  • Air Conditioning
  • Waterfront
  • Wheelchair Accessible

East Meredith Specialty for Sale

Exceptional 107-Acre Multi-Use Estate - All cash offers accepted for review This remarkable 107-acre property offers a rare combination of natural beauty, established infrastructure, and unlimited potential. Located in a town with no zoning restrictions. A truly rare offering—this extraordinary property presents a unique opportunity to own a naturally established landscape with endless possibilities. Set across expansive acreage, the land features a harmonious blend of open meadows, mature woodlands, and serene water elements, creating a setting that feels both private and timeless. Whether you're seeking a private estate, family compound, or an investment with vision, this property provides the flexibility to bring your ideas to life. The diverse terrain allows for multiple uses, including a multi-generational retreat, restaurant, event venue, agricultural venture, or hospitality concept such as cabins or eco-lodging. Unlike raw land, this property has already been shaped by years of natural growth, offering established ecosystems, scenic views, and a peaceful atmosphere that changes beautifully with the seasons. It’s a space that feels complete—yet still open to transformation. Create a secluded family compound with room to expand, design a destination experience, or simply enjoy the privacy and beauty of your own natural sanctuary. Opportunities like this are increasingly rare—where the land not only offers what it is today, but what it can become tomorrow. Surrounded by natural beauty and a sense of quiet seclusion, the property invites a lifestyle that is both relaxed and inspiring. Gentle transitions between open and wooded areas create ideal spaces for walking trails, outdoor gathering areas, or thoughtfully designed structures that blend seamlessly into the landscape. The presence of water features enhances the overall experience, offering calming views, potential recreational use, and an added sense of tranquility that is difficult to replicate. For those envisioning a family compound, the scale and layout provide ample room for multiple residences while still maintaining privacy between living spaces. Imagine generations gathering in one place—shared spaces balanced with personal retreats, all within a setting that feels connected to nature. At the same time, entrepreneurs and visionaries will recognize the potential to develop something truly unique, whether that means a boutique destination, curated event space, or an income-producing property tailored to modern demand for experiential environments. Access, usability, and natural character combine to create a property that is both practical and inspiring. With thoughtful planning, it can evolve into a legacy holding—something to enjoy today while continuing to grow in value and purpose over time. Endless opportunity. Unlimited potential. A property ready to become whatever you envision. We are open to cash offers! Property Features - Buildings & Facilities Primary/Caretaker residence Full-service restaurant (easily convertible to a private residence or lodge) Working micro-brewery Hops Yard Band Stage Large event barn Separate event house Multiple storage barns Greenhouses Fully equipped workshop Plant nursery Chicken coops Extensive parking areas Land & Natural Features 23 ponds throughout the property Two flowing streams Scenic woodlands and open fields Orchard Mature natural gardens and landscaped areas Gazebo and decorative bridges Stunning panoramic views Infrastructure 1.5 miles of road frontage Ownership of both sides of the road 11 real bathrooms located throughout the property for events and visitors Opportunity & Potential This property is perfectly suited for a wide range of uses, including: Destination event venue / wedding venue Agri-tourism resort Brewery and restaurant destination Farm market and nursery Private estate or retreat Eco-tourism property Campground or glamping resort

Contact:

Natural Gardens

Date on Market:

2026-03-12

Hide
See More
More details for 1354 US Highway 20, West Winfield, NY - Hospitality for Sale

Jeannies Dream Motel - 1354 US Highway 20

West Winfield, NY 13491

  • Motel
  • Hospitality for Sale
  • $909,465 CAD
  • 5,435 SF
See More
More details for 396 Elizabethtown Rd, Ilion, NY - Specialty for Sale

396 Elizabethtown Rd

Ilion, NY 13357

  • Motel
  • Specialty for Sale
  • $1,171,295 CAD
  • 10,578 SF
See More

Motels For Sale

Motels

Looking to lease a Motel? View Motels for lease