Columbus Retail for Sale - East

This offering provides a truly passive investment with a long-term absolute NNN lease, zero landlord responsibilities and ensuring stable cash flow. The property is operated by the largest Tim Hortons franchisee in the U.S., offering strong operational backing and reliability from an experienced operator tied to a nationally recognized brand. Located on a high-traffic, signalized corner in a dense retail corridor, the site benefits from excellent visibility, modern drive-thru construction, and strong surrounding demographics. Positioned in one of the brand’s strongest U.S. markets, the asset is well-supported by population growth and consistent quick-service demand.

Property Subtype:

Fast Food

Date on Market:

2026-04-15

Columbus Portfolio of properties for Sale - North Central

1030–1046 N. High Street presents a rare opportunity to acquire two connected mixed-use buildings on one of Columbus’ most dynamic commercial corridors—the heart of the Short North Arts District. Offered at $5 million, this property spans roughly 17,597 SF across two buildings and sits on three parcels totaling 0.3144 acres. Current tenants include two well-known restaurant and bar concepts, as well as a retail boutique, providing immediate income with potential for significant value-add upside through apartment and office lease-up. These historic buildings feature large street-facing windows, excellent visibility, and an outdoor patio amenity that enhances pedestrian engagement. With zoning (UCR 2113-2024) allowing mixed-use under the Italian Village Historic District, the property supports redevelopment or creative repositioning. Located minutes from downtown Columbus, OSU campus, and major regional destinations such as the Arena District and the Convention Center, this offering benefits from dense foot traffic and accessibility to highways and public transit. For investors seeking a high-demand location with long-term appreciation and adaptable income streams, this Short North assemblage combines authenticity, flexibility, and scale in an irreplaceable setting.

Date on Market:

2026-04-15

Dublin Retail for Sale

Tutor Time is dedicated to fostering education development, building self-esteem, and sparking imagination in a safe and loving environment. As a leader in early child education and family solutions, Tutor Time is committed to developing innovative educational solutions. There are approximately 125 corporate Tutor Time schools throughout the United States. Dublin is a vibrant city located in central Ohio. As a suburb of the state capital, Columbus, Dublin offers a blend of suburban comfort, economic vitality, and a strong sense of community. With a population of approximately 50,000 residents, it’s known for its excellent schools, green spaces, and a range of amenities.

Property Subtype:

Day Care Center

Date on Market:

2026-04-14

Columbus Retail for Sale - North Central

Located at the signalized intersection of Hudson Street and North High Street, this highly visible mixed-use asset presents a strong opportunity in the Commercial Real Estate market. The property is surrounded by established national and regional retailers, benefiting from consistent traffic along one of the area’s most active corridors. The asset features a combination of street-level retail and multifamily units, catering to ongoing demand for mixed-use properties in urban infill locations. Positioned less than five minutes from The Ohio State University, the site draws from a dense and highly active population base. With convenient access to Columbus’ downtown core and the Arena District, the property offers strong connectivity to major employment centers, entertainment venues, and regional amenities—supporting long-term demand in a competitive commercial real estate market.

Property Subtype:

Storefront Retail/Residential

Date on Market:

2026-04-10

Columbus Retail for Sale - North Central

• Size/Acreage: 5,300 SF on 1.40 Acres • Zoning: Mixed-Use, UNG-1 (City of Columbus) • Doors: 2 Drive-in (10’ X 8’) • Clear Height: 11’-13’ • Interior: Showroom (previous Auto Parts and Mattress retail) with a Kitchen and two restrooms • Enterprise Zone: Central Enterprise Zone (City of Columbus) • Location: Cleveland Ave near E. North Broadway with easy access to I-70, & SR-3. On COTA’s Bus Rapid Transit line C-MAX • Parking: 30 vehicle spaces in Front Lot, Fenced in lot in rear with electric remote-controlled gate for equipment parking • Two parcels to the South totaling 0.593 acres are vacant and ready for redevelopment.

Property Subtype:

Freestanding

Date on Market:

2026-04-09

Dublin Office for Sale

Positioned in the core of Historic Dublin, 37 W. Bridge Street offers a rare, fully leased multi-tenant asset with immediate income and clear upside. The combination of irreplaceable character, walkable location, and strong tenant mix makes this a highly marketable opportunity with both investor and owner-user appeal. ? Highlights: • 7,092 SF historic multi-tenant office/retail asset • 100% occupied with 7 tenants providing in-place cash flow • Pro forma supports 6%+ cap rate with NNN structure • Prime walkable location between Old Dublin, Bridge Park, and Riverview Village • Over 100 adjacent public parking spaces plus 500+ nearby • Well-maintained with minimal near-term capital needs • Strong owner-user flexibility with income in place

Date on Market:

2026-04-01

Columbus Industrial for Sale - North Central

1125 Cleveland Avenue represents a compelling opportunity for an owner-user to acquire a well-equipped 9,216 SF industrial facility in a prime central Columbus location. The combination of functional warehouse space, office/showroom buildout, and two drive-in doors, creates a highly practical environment for a wide range of industrial and service-oriented businesses. The property’s layout supports efficient day-to-day operations, while its location ensures strong connectivity to major highways, downtown Columbus, and surrounding neighborhoods. Whether used for manufacturing, contracting, logistics, or storage, the site provides the infrastructure needed to operate effectively today while also offering flexibility for future growth.

Property Subtype:

Warehouse

Date on Market:

2026-04-01

Columbus Retail for Sale - Hilliard

Property Subtype:

Vet/Kennel

Date on Market:

2026-03-24

Worthington Retail for Sale

Introducing a prime investment or owner/user opportunity at 5625 N High St, Worthington, OH. This 8,400 SF free-standing retail and office building, constructed in 1959, boasts a versatile C-2 zoning, ideal for retail or office use. Meticulously maintained, the property accommodates 24 on-site parking spaces and offers prominent pylon and building signage opportunities. Situated in a thriving Worthington submarket, its strategic location provides convenient access to major thoroughfares. With the potential for owner occupancy of 4,337 SF, this property represents an exceptional prospect for investors or owner-users seeking a well-located and dynamic commercial space.

Property Subtype:

Storefront Retail/Office

Date on Market:

2026-03-13

Reynoldsburg Retail for Sale - East

This single-tenant investment opportunity features a free-standing restaurant positioned on approximately 1.15 acres along Brice Road, a highly trafficked commercial corridor in Reynoldsburg, Ohio. The property is subject to a new 5-year lease with an established operator and includes renewal options, ensuring dependable cash flow and continuity for ownership. Offered at $980,000 with an 8.85% cap rate, the site provides a solid return profile for investors seeking stable income-generating assets. The building benefits from excellent visibility and accessibility, located near the I-70 Brice Road interchange, a key east-west route offering smooth connectivity throughout the Columbus metropolitan area. With 120 on-site parking spaces and zoning under the Community Activity Center designation, the property is designed to support high-volume restaurant operations and customer convenience. Prominent pylon signage further enhances exposure. Owner financing may be available, creating additional flexibility for qualified buyers. This asset is well-suited for investors who value strong traffic counts, long-term tenancy, and adaptable retail positioning within a thriving suburban market.

Property Subtype:

Restaurant

Date on Market:

2026-03-13

Upper Arlington Retail for Sale - Grandview/Upper Arlington

• Own or Lease a Restaurant in an established location in Upper Arlington on RTE. 33 / Riverside Dr. with approximately ± 31,673 VPD • Currently known as Eastern Bay Chinese Restaurant with 3,415 Sq Ft on two lots totaling approximately 1.033 acres • Extra parking and drive through window capabilities • Opportunity to purchase, lease, or redevelop with a ground lease • Equipment not included • Business is currently operating, do not disturb tenants

Property Subtype:

Restaurant

Date on Market:

2026-03-13

Columbus Retail for Sale - West

• The lease is guaranteed by an established franchisee (150+ Unit Operator) • 15 years remaining with 4 (5-year) option periods to extend • The lease features 1.50% annual rental increases throughout the initial term and options, providing a hedge against inflation and steadily growing NOI • Founded in 1950, Dunkin’ is among America’s favorite coffee and baked goods with over 13,700 operating stores

Property Subtype:

Fast Food

Date on Market:

2026-03-03

Reynoldsburg Retail for Sale - East

Investment Opportunity. SLAB BBQ leased this great location in July 2025. The entire building was built out and remodeled in 2020, TI Improvements in 2025. New 5 year lease with renewals. 9.5% CAP Rate This downtown Reynoldsburg location features off street parking, Full Kitchen, Open Patio and Balcony seating for a great year around atmosphere. Exposed Brick, warm environment for this incredible restaurant. Additional Public Parking is adjoining on the corner of Main and Lancaster. Reynoldsburg has invested in Street Improvements and makes this location extremely desirable for long term success. Perfect for Investor and great for 1031 Exchange. NNN Lease.

Property Subtype:

Restaurant

Date on Market:

2026-03-02

Columbus Retail for Sale - North Central

PRIME LOCATION! Commercial building and land for sale. 2,440 SF currently used as a church on 0.37 acres with 370 SF outbuilding zoned C3 - Commercial. Also included is 0.62 acres of vacant land zoned R - Residential. Vacant land can be sold separately (Parcel #010-167524) Property sits in a highly accessible part of Columbus, offering quick connections to major thoroughfares like I-270, I-70, and I-71. The area around Brentnell has seen increased interest from investors and developers, benefiting from broader Columbus growth patterns -- including retail reinvestment, transportation upgrades, and neighborhood revitalization efforts. Building includes parking lot with 23 spaces, NEW ROOF, New Furnace and AC (2024/2025) that were all permitted. Includes Men and Women's bathrooms, two offices, new carpet & lighting in 2025! Already set up for a church, pews and stage are included with the sale. Small additional building was built in 2025.

Property Subtype:

Freestanding

Date on Market:

2026-02-25

Columbus Retail for Sale - East

Surmount is pleased to present the exclusive listing for a Meineke Car Care located at 2260 East Livingston Avenue, Columbus, OH 43209. The site consists of roughly 4,097 rentable square feet of building space on an estimated 0.50-acre parcel of land. This Meineke Car Care is subject to a 20-year Triple Net (NNN) lease, which commenced 11/10/2025. The current annual rent is $82,586 and has scheduled increases of 10.00% every 5 years.

Property Subtype:

Auto Repair

Date on Market:

2026-02-19

Dublin Retail for Sale

+/- 4,152 SF single-tenant retail space in one of the most difficult-to-penetrate markets in the Columbus, Ohio metro area. Directly across from Dublin Plaza—a Kroger-anchored center that hosts 108,400 visits per month (source: Placer.ai). Full access from both SR-161/US-33 (Bridge Street) and Corbins Mill Drive. Pylon and monument signage that is grandfathered into Dublin sign code. 29,443 vehicles per day on SR-161/US-33. 27 parking spaces (6.5 per 1,000 SF). Excellent demographics—median HH income over $108,437.

Date on Market:

2026-02-09

Columbus Retail for Sale - Southeast

Court Appointed Receiver Sale, 1220-1222 Parsons Ave, a mixed-use investment property located in close proximity to Nationwide Children’s Hospital, with convenient access to Downtown Columbus, German Village, and major highway corridors including I-70 and I-71. The building features three total units, consisting of one street-level retail space, one 2-bedroom, 1 bathroom, and one 1-bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment units. The property is visually distinctive, with large-scale murals on two sides of the building that enhance street presence and visibility. Dedicated off-street parking adds functional value for both residential and retail occupants. The apartment units have been previously updated with newer flooring, stainless steel appliances, quartz countertops, upgraded cabinetry, tiled backsplashes, and tiled bathrooms. The combination of updated residential units and street-level retail provides diversified income potential in a high-demand location. This asset is well-suited for investors or owner-users seeking a mixed-use property near a major employment and medical hub. Property Information and Showings Please contact Kurt at kurt@prodigyprop.com with questions or to schedule a tour.  Receiver may, in its sole discretion, accept or reject any offer or bid, for any reason, at any time, without notice

Property Subtype:

Storefront Retail/Residential

Date on Market:

2026-02-04

Columbus Retail for Sale - Southwest

Retail Investment Opportunity

Property Subtype:

Storefront

Date on Market:

2026-02-02

Columbus Office for Sale - East

Online Foreclosure Auction with bidding ending on Thurs. May 21 at Noon. The opening bid is $2,400,000 based on a $4,200,000 appraisal. See OhioSheriffSales dotcom for full details and to bid online. Text the Auctioneer for an easy showing. A rare East Columbus medical/office redevelopment opportunity on 3.50 acres with 62,500± SF of space across four floors. This high-visibility asset sits directly on E. Broad Street near the Hamilton Road medical corridor and offers tremendous repositioning potential for medical, dental, behavioral health, professional office, senior care, or mixed-use conversion. Currently approximately 25% occupied but the tenant will be moving out, the building features a functioning medical office footprint on select floors with half of the first floor and all of the third floor gutted, ready for build-out. Investors will appreciate this flexible blank canvas. Constructed in 1974 with major modernization in 2010–2015, the building offers: Fire-resistant construction and concrete panel exterior Hydraulic passenger elevators (2 units) Full building sprinkler system Central HVAC & standard medical office mechanicals 12-ft wall heights 15,625 SF per floor (4 floors) Large asphalt parking lot with extensive paving The property is located in the Columbus–Gahanna Jefferson School District, surrounded by dense residential neighborhoods, national retailers, medical users, and major employment centers. With a 2024 auditor valuation of $3,774,200 and significant upside through lease-up and renovation, this property presents an exceptional distressed-asset investment in a supply-limited medical office submarket. Corner location with multiple ingress/egress. Large Monument Signage. Do not miss this value-add opportunity! Lot Size: 3.462 Acres with 75,000 SF of parking Annual Taxes: $95,225

Property Subtype:

Medical

Date on Market:

2025-06-20

Columbus Retail for Sale - Westerville

Property Subtype:

Freestanding

Date on Market:

2026-01-29

Columbus Retail for Sale - Downtown

4,992 +/- SF mixed-use investment property for sale just south of Downtown. Two retail units on ground floor, two apartment units above. Building has third floor finish possibilities (unfinished attic) covering entire footprint of space - potential to add 3,000 SF living space with great view of Downtown Skyline. Great location in bustling German Village - Close to Schiller Park, Columbus Brewery District, Scioto Audubon Metro Park and more. Short drives into Downtown Columbus or to major highways I-70 and I-71. PLEASE DO NOT DISTURB TENANTS.

Property Subtype:

Storefront Retail/Residential

Date on Market:

2026-01-15

Columbus Retail for Sale - West

3 Store fronts and 8 renovated studio apartments on 2nd floor. Upstairs rented at $5650/month. 1 of 3 store fronts occupied. The other two lofts are being prepared for lease. Large basement for storage, etc.

Property Subtype:

Storefront Retail/Residential

Date on Market:

2026-01-14

Columbus Retail for Sale - East

GREAT OPPORTUNITY TO OWN THIS COMMERCIAL RETAIL BUILDING WITH WAREHOUSE & STORAGE AREA. PROPERTY INCLUDES CUSTOMER & EMPLOYEE PARKING. AWESOME LOCATION BETWEEN BEXLEY & WHITEHALL. BUILDING IS CURRENTLY BEING USED AS A PAWN SHOP BUSINESS. INVENTORY & BUSINESS CAN BE SOLD SEPARATELY IF BUYER IS INTERESTED IN A TURNKEY BUSINESS. * IF BUYER IS INTERESTED IN BUSINESS & INVENTORY PURCHASE PLEASE CONTACT LISTING AGENT. ** IF BUYER WILL NOT BE PURCHASING BUSINESS AND WILL BE USING THE PROPERTY FOR SOMETHING ELSE SELLER WOULD LIKE TO CLOSE WITH A 120 DAY RENT-BACK AFTER CLOSING. SELLER WILL MAKE THE PROPERTY AVAILABLE FOR CONTRACTORS, ARCHITECTS ETC FOR PLANNING DURNING RENT-BACK PERIOD.

Property Subtype:

Freestanding

Date on Market:

2026-01-10

Columbus Retail for Sale - Downtown East

This solid brick building is offered in shell condition and requires a complete interior redevelopment, presenting a compelling opportunity for adaptive reuse. The property includes two first-floor retail spaces, a rear first-floor apartment, four second-floor apartments, and a large rear lot suitable for parking or future expansion. Constructed on a stone foundation, the building features a large basement beneath the east-side retail space and retains original mosaic tile on the west side, adding architectural character. Recent capital improvements include a new roof, gutters, and soffits. Located near new residential developments along Main and Cherry Streets and within one mile of Nationwide Children’s Hospital, which is undergoing a $1 Billion expansion, and Grant Medical Center, which is in the midst of a $400 million expansion, the property sits in a rapidly reinvesting corridor anchored by major institutional investment. Eligible for tax abatement through the City of Columbus, this offering presents strong long-term investment potential in an emerging urban market.

Property Subtype:

Storefront Retail/Residential

Date on Market:

2026-01-08