Copiague Retail for Sale - Southwestern Suffolk

Cushman & Wakefield is pleased to offer, on an exclusive basis, the sale of 1179–1183 Sunrise Highway, a 19,344-square-foot free-standing building on 1.09 acres in Copiague. Situated between Target and Home Depot on NY Route 27 with over 47,000 daily vehicles, the property offers exceptional visibility and access for showroom, retail, office, or industrial operations. The flexible floor plan and ample on-site parking support furniture, home goods, automotive, appliance, or specialty product showrooms seeking high-traffic exposure in a proven South Shore retail corridor with strong residential density.

Property Subtype:

Freestanding

Date on Market:

2026-02-12

Middle Island Retail for Sale - Central Suffolk

American Investment Properties is retained to sell the property located at 846-900 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island. At this location is a large retail neighborhood center consisting of several tenants. Most tenants are on long-term leases with options to extend. There are currently 2 vacant spaces that provide for great lease-up opportunities. This property has vast frontage on Middle Country Rd and ample on-site parking for the convenience of shoppers.

Property Subtype:

Storefront

Date on Market:

2026-02-12

Miller Place Retail for Sale - Central Suffolk

The automotive repair business is included with the building and has operated at this location for over 20 years. The property is zoned J-2.

Property Subtype:

Auto Repair

Date on Market:

2026-02-11

Bay Shore Retail for Sale - Southwestern Suffolk

Marcus & Millichap is pleased to present the subject offering, a single-tenant net-leased Sunoco gas station located on Howells Road in Bay Shore (Long Island), New York. The lease is corporately guaranteed by Sunoco, LP, North America’s largest independent fuel distributor with $20 billion in annual revenue, and a market capitalization of $14.5 billion. The site features an Exxon Mobil-branded gas station with ten pumps, and a 1,380 square foot building that houses Hamza & Madina Halal Food, a restaurant chain with 13 locations throughout NYC and Long Island. The property rests on a 17,424 square foot corner lot. This is an absolute NNN lease, with zero landlord responsibilities. Sunoco has two percent annual increase, with two (5) five-year renewal options. Sunoco LP recently purchased this lease. This is offered fee simple, and it is eligible for accelerated depreciation. The offering is located on Howells Road, just off Sunrise Highway, the major commercial roadway in Bay Shore. The site is down the street from a massive retail complex featuring Lowe’s, Old Navy, Barnes & Noble, Target and HomeGoods. It is right down the street from Bay Shore High School (1,900+ students), and it benefits from outstanding traffic counts along Sunrise Highway and the Southern State Parkway. Bay Shore is located on the South Shore in Suffolk County (Long Island).

Property Subtype:

Service Station

Date on Market:

2026-02-06

Smithtown Retail for Sale - Central Suffolk

Ron Kleinberg of Tri-State Properties has been selected as the exclusive selling broker for the Galleria Terry, a 6,000-square-foot retail center located at 117 Terry Road in Smithtown. The property offers a unique opportunity for a user-investor, featuring 3,040 square feet of centrally located space ideal for an owner-occupant, while generating income from two existing tenants. The available space was most recently occupied by a bagel café and is well suited for a wide range of commercial uses, benefiting from the center’s layout, surrounding residential density, and strong demographic profile.

Property Subtype:

Freestanding

Date on Market:

2026-02-05

Lindenhurst Retail for Sale - Southwestern Suffolk

Marcus & Millichap is proud to present for sale 718-724 N Wellwood Avenue ("Subject property"), a retail strip center located in Lindenhurst, NY. The subject property rests on a 0.22-acre parcel with approximately +/- 5,805 square feet of space. This property consists of four stores and currently has one vacancy. The subject property has on-site parking on the southside of the building. This portion of N Wellwood Avenue is a high traffic thoroughfare that sees 29,560 VPD. The subject property is ideally located near numerous retailers like King Kullen, McDonald’s, Chase Bank, 7 Eleven and much more. The area demographics paint a picture of opportunity – over 148,000 people live within a three miles radius and an average household income is well over $141,000. Additional information is available upon request.

Property Subtype:

Storefront Retail/Office

Date on Market:

2026-02-04

Smithtown Retail for Sale - Western Suffolk

American Investment Properties is retained to sell 35 W Main St, Smithtown, NY. At this location is a retail and office building consisting of (1) retail space on the ground floor and (3) office spaces on the second floor. This building was newly renovated in 2023 and is located within walking distance to the Smithtown LIRR train station.

Property Subtype:

Storefront Retail/Office

Date on Market:

2024-09-10

Lindenhurst Retail for Sale - Southwestern Suffolk

The Property is located at the southwest corner of Montauk Highway and Granada Parkway. Formerly occupied by Enterprise Rent-A-Car for 20+ years, the building is approximately 750 square feet, presenting an ideal owner-user or redevelopment opportunity. The 12,169 square foot lot offers ample on-site parking for customers and employees. The property is zoned E Business, which permits general retail stores and personal service shops, banks, and offices. Additional permitted uses allowed as a special exception by the Board of Appeals include veterinarians, car washes, auto-related sales & service, and food establishments (subject to additional conditions imposed by the Planning Board). The property is located in Suffolk County Sewer District 3.

Property Subtype:

Freestanding

Date on Market:

2026-01-30

Southampton Retail for Sale - Eastern Suffolk

Freestanding Commercial Building Rare VB-Zoned Property with Private Parking in the Southampton Village Core Exceptional Accessibility in Prime Village Location – Located in the heart of Southampton Village’s Business District, this 0.25-acre property offers a rare freestanding commercial building with on-site parking - an increasingly scarce feature within the Village core. The property’s clean stucco façade and central positioning make it a strong presence along one of the area’s most established corridors. Versatile Two-Level Layout with Private Parking – The 2,640sf structure is currently configured for single-tenant use but can be easily adapted for multi-tenant occupancy. The ground floor offers open-plan retail or office space with high ceilings, while the upper level provides additional workspace or storage. The layout includes one full bathroom and one half bathroom, adding significant operational flexibility for both staff and client needs. Furthermore, an on-site generator ensures stable, uninterrupted operations, which is a critical asset for medical, professional, or retail users. The site also includes 15 parking spaces plus a two-car garage, providing unmatched convenience in a high-traffic area. Flexible VB Zoning with Broad Use Potential – Village Business zoning allows for an extensive range of commercial uses, including bank, professional or medical office, personal service, and retail. Special Exception uses further expand the property’s potential, including restaurant or second-floor apartments. The property’s adaptability makes it ideal for investors or those seeking a long-term headquarters. Asking Price: $2,450,000 Tax ID #: 006.000-0005-008.000 2024 Town Tax Bill: $3,503.52 2025 Village Tax Bill: $3,006.67 Surrounding Neighbors: Fellingham's Restaurant, Chase Bank, 75 Main, Citarella, Herrick Hardware, Bluemercury, Sant Ambroeus, London Jewelers

Property Subtype:

Freestanding

Date on Market:

2026-01-28

Saint James Retail for Sale - Western Suffolk

Cushman & Wakefield is pleased to exclusively present 420 N Country Road, St James. The subject asset is a fully built out restaurant and bar offered as a complete package including the fee-simple real estate and all FF&E. The ±6,000 SF, single-story freestanding building sits on a 0.60-acre parcel with 25 on-site parking spaces, fronting NY-25A in St. James, New York, and has been recently renovated and meticulously maintained. 420 N Country Road provides a turnkey restaurant platform, with all kitchen, bar, and back-of-house infrastructure included. Located one mile from the St. James LIRR station and surrounded by affluent residential neighborhoods and limited competing supply, the property benefits from strong local demand and long-term barriers to entry. Zoned Central Business (CB), the asset supports continued operations or concept rebranding. The offering includes all components required for uninterrupted operations, including: Commercial kitchen equipment, Bar build-out and service infrastructure, Dining room furniture and fixtures, POS systems, Back-of-house equipment and storage, Mechanical, electrical, and operational systems. The buyer will acquire a fully functioning restaurant facility, enabling immediate operational continuity or seamless transition to a new concept.

Property Subtype:

Restaurant

Date on Market:

2026-01-22

Commack Retail for Sale - Western Suffolk

First time offered, this CVS Pharmacy investment at 341 Commack Road in Commack, NY represents a rare opportunity to acquire a high-performing drugstore location along one of Long Island’s strongest retail corridors. The store generates exceptional sales volume, placing it in CVS’s top-performing locations nationwide and reinforcing the strength of the real estate and long-term tenant demand. The property is positioned on heavily trafficked Commack Road, surrounded by dense, affluent residential neighborhoods with average household incomes exceeding $160,000 within one mile. The combination of irreplaceable location fundamentals, proven retail performance, and a newly structured long-term leasehold component makes this offering a compelling acquisition for investors seeking increased depreciation, durable cash flow, supported by real-world operating strength.

Property Subtype:

Drug Store

Date on Market:

2026-01-20

Ridge Retail for Sale - Central Suffolk

Offered for sale is a ±3,486 SF professional office building located on highly visible Middle Country Road (Route 25) in Ridge, New York. The property features four units (A–D) with a combined owner-user suite of approximately 1,800 SF, plus additional lease-up upside, making this an ideal opportunity for both owner-occupants and investors. The building is zoned J4 Business, permitting a wide range of professional and business office uses including medical, financial, and service-oriented occupancies. The site provides 21 on-site parking spaces and excellent signage exposure along one of Suffolk County’s primary commercial corridors. In-Place & Pro Forma Financials (Taxes Only) Double Net: Asking Price: $1,200,000 Gross Potential Rent: Pro forma at ~$26.00/SF Real Estate Taxes (2025): $17,545.90 Net Operating Income: $72,359.10 Cap Rate @ Asking Price: 6.0% Traffic & Exposure: NYSDOT Traffic Data (COSIT 070040000000) for Middle Country Road (Route 25) reports: AADT: 7,528 (2023 Actual) AADT: 7,131 (2024 Estimated) Truck Percentage: 6% This confirms consistent daily traffic volumes supporting strong visibility and tenant demand along the Route 25 corridor. Investment Highlights: Hybrid owner-user / value-add profile Route 25 frontage with NYSDOT-verified traffic counts Flexible J4 zoning Strong Long Island professional office market Near-term vacancy upside with stabilized cash flow potential

Property Subtype:

Freestanding

Date on Market:

2026-01-16

East Northport Retail for Sale - Western Suffolk

Property Subtype:

Storefront

Date on Market:

2026-01-16

Melville Retail for Sale - Western Suffolk

Property Subtype:

Storefront

Date on Market:

2026-01-15

Smithtown Retail for Sale - Western Suffolk

Surmount is pleased to present the exclusive listing for a Citibank located at 730 Veterans Memorial Highway, Hauppauge, NY 11788. The site consists of roughly 11,410 rentable square feet of building space on an estimated 2.54-acre parcel of land. This Citibank is subject to a 12-year Triple Net (NNN) lease. The current annual rent is $400,000 and has scheduled increases of 1.00% annually, starting 2028.

Date on Market:

2026-01-14

Patchogue Retail for Sale - Central Suffolk

The property consists of 4 buildings. They are 100 percent occupied with month-to-month leases. An apartment complex is being built directly adjacent to the property. An assisted living facility is being built across the street. This area of East Patchogue is booming. The owner's family has owned the property for over 100 years when it was built as car dealerships for Cadillac- LaSalle, Packard, and Studebaker. The floors under the carpet on the main building are Terrazzo. The owner also owns the right of way through the property giving his tenants full access to all of the property. There is 25,800 square feet of space comprised of four buildings.

Property Subtype:

Freestanding

Date on Market:

2026-01-14

Copiague Retail for Sale - Southwestern Suffolk

- Rare Long Island NNN Property -Brand New 15-Year Lease -Corporate Backed -Zero LL Responsibility -2.5% Annual Increases Additional Info Available Upon Request

Property Subtype:

Auto Repair

Date on Market:

2026-01-13

Shirley Retail for Sale - Eastern Suffolk

Calling All Investors, Developers & End-Users!!! 7.11 Cap MINT 10,000+ Sqft. Retail Building With NNN National Tenant On Montauk Hwy. For Sale!!! The Property Features Excellent Signage, Great Exposure, Long Term Lease, J2 Zoning, 58 Parking Spaces, High 20’ Ceilings, Sprinklers, Drive-Thru, 3 Phase Power, 2 Strategically Placed Curb Cuts, All New LED Lighting, CAC, +++!!! The Property Is Located In The Heart Of Shirley On Busy Montauk Hwy. Just 1 Block From William Floyd Pkwy.!!! Neighbors Include Starbucks, The Home Depot, USPS, UPS, Stop & Shop, Ulta Beauty, Kohl’s, Marshalls, Dunkin’, Kay Jewelers, CVS, Applebee’s Bar & Grill, King Kullen, McDonald’s, Taco Bell, Wendy’s, Sonic, Enterprise Rent-A-Car, Aldi, Lidl, Dollar Tree, STS Tire, Jersey Mike’s Subs, Carvel, KFC, +++!!! The Property Has 287’ Of Frontage On Montauk Hwy. + 177’ Of Frontage On Grand Ave.!!! The Property Has A Daily Traffic Count Of 42,000+ Vehicles Per Day!!! This Property Offers HUGE Upside Potential!!! This Could Be Your Next Development Site Or The Next Home For Your Business!!! Income: Walgreens: $505,000 NNN Ann.; Flat Rent; Lease Exp.: 2036. Gross Income: $505,000 Ann. Expenses: Oil: $0 (NNN Lease) Electric: $0 (NNN Lease) Water: $0 (NNN Lease) Maintenance & Repairs: $0 (NNN Lease) Insurance: $0 (NNN Lease) Taxes: $0 (NNN Lease) Total Expenses: $0 (NNN Lease) Net Operating Income (NOI): $505,000 Ann. (7.11% Cap!!!)

Property Subtype:

Drug Store

Date on Market:

2026-01-13

Amityville Retail for Sale - Southwestern Suffolk

Bolla land lease 5% increases every 5 years : Sunoco gasoline with Tim Hortons convenience, store, newly constructed two years ago , 4.48% cap. Other locations available. Please contact Tom Zomerfeld at (631) 766-1333 for more information.

Property Subtype:

Service Station

Date on Market:

2026-01-12

East Northport Retail for Sale - Western Suffolk

American Investment Properties is retained to sell the property at 3021-3023 Jericho Turnpike, East Northport, New York. At this location is a retail strip center that has an additional 2,200 SF of mezzanine storage space. There is currently one vacancy at the property which provides for a great lease-up opportunity. The property sits on the busy Jericho Turnpike which sees over 37,000 vehicles per day. It's a quarter mile from Huntington Mall, Home Depot, and surrounded by other neighborhood amenities.

Property Subtype:

Storefront

Date on Market:

2026-01-08

East Islip Retail for Sale - Southwestern Suffolk

+/- 1,700sf on 0.4 Acres Detached 2 Car Garage Zoning: GST Unique Opportunity for Use Possible: Law Office, CPA, Medical Office, Daycare 175 ft Main Road Frontage

Property Subtype:

Bar

Date on Market:

2026-01-07

Brookhaven Retail for Sale - Central Suffolk

American Investment Properties is retained to sell the multi-use property located at 2815 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven. At this location are 5 buildings consisting of a gas station, a mechanic's shop, a deli, a barn, and a house. Both the deli and the gas station have 5% annual increases in rent and the house rent is month-to-month. This is a great opportunity located in Brookhaven, NY.

Property Subtype:

Service Station

Date on Market:

2025-12-30

Amityville Retail for Sale - Southwestern Suffolk

Calling All Investors, Developers & End-Users!!! Prime Mixed Use Building/ Development Site On Route 110 For Sale!!! The Property Features Great Exposure, Excellent Signage, High 8’ Ceilings, (480) Multiple Use Zoning, 18 Parking Spaces, Office, (1) 2 Br. Apartment, (1) 1 Br. Apartment, (1) Studio Apt., Full Basement, Low Property Taxes, Private Driveway & Parking Lot, Large Fenced Yard, Strategically Placed Curb Cuts, 200 Amp Power, All New LED LIghting, +++!!! This Huge 17,000+ Sqft. Property Is Situated In The Heart Of Amityville On Busy Route 110 Just North Of Sunrise Highway!!! Neighbors Include Starbucks, The Home Depot, Target, Mercedes-Benz, Kia, Nissan, 7-Eleven, Valero, Sunoco, McDonald's, Taco Bell, Pollo Campero, KFC, Walgreens, Advance Auto Parts, T-Mobile, Red Lobster, Dollar Tree, +++!!! The Property Has A Traffic Count Of 31,400+ Vehicles Per Day!!! The Entire Building Can Be Delivered Vacant If Need Be. This Property Has HUGE Upside Potential!!! This Could Be Your Next Development Site Or The Next Home For Your Business!!! Income: 1st Fl. 2 Br. Apt.: $33,600 Ann. (Available) 2nd Fl. 1 Br. Apt.: $26,400 Ann. (Available) 3rd. Fl. Studio Apt.: $21,600 Ann. (Available) 1st Fl. Office (350 Sqft.): $22,800 Ann. (Available) Full LL: $9,600 Ann. (Available) Pro Forma Gross Income: $114,000 Ann. Expenses: Gas: $0 Ann. Electric: $0 Ann. Maintenance & Repairs: $250 Ann. Insurance: $2,823 Ann. Water: $800 Ann. Taxes: $11,437.09 Ann. Total Expenses: $15,310.09 Ann. Pro Forma Net Operating Income (NOI): $98.689.91 Ann. (11.96% Cap!!!)

Date on Market:

2025-12-29

Commack Retail for Sale - Western Suffolk

Surmount is pleased to present the exclusive listing for a Friendly’s located at 2151 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725. Th e site consists of roughly 4,798 rentable square feet of building space on an estimated 1.01 -acre parcel of land. This Friendly’s is subject to a Triple Net (NNN) lease, which has over 13 years of term remaining. The current annual rent is $219,971 and has scheduled increases of 2.00% Annually.

Property Subtype:

Restaurant

Date on Market:

2025-12-19